[Philosophy] What’s in a Name? Everything….

It has been a while since I did a ‘thinky’ blog post (and excuse me for using that word but it’s been a long and lazzzy weekend, first one I can remember, and I’m chilled and not so much of a grammer-fascist as I normally try to be). I was going to do a fluffy pink post drooling and squeeing over a certain dress a very good friend bought for me, but that one can wait as, gasp, I had a request for a blog post.

Firstly, anyone can ask me for a blog post on any topic they like; I really like the challenge of a topic and my brain is pretty empty after the x years I’ve been writing this and secondly i was kinda thinking of writing a blog post about just this topic when a very good friend of mine challenged me to write it.

Pictured – it’s a philosophical post so there will be lots of lovely pictures to water down the seriousness. I call this ‘le Sarah’ for obvious reasons

The impetus to write a post on names and identity came from a lovely comment someone sent me; they had started at the very beginning of the blog and asked, candidly, why my attitude towards ‘Sarah’ had changed so radically, in the way I refer to her/me. At the start of the blog it was very much third person; referring to her as a separate entity with a very strong division between the personalities. As the years went by the her became me, and the blog posts shifted to a perspective of first person.

So the question my friend asked me was quite direct and, initially, quite a simple one. “why, If you chose to live as a woman, it would not be under the name of Sarah but Julia”.

It got me thinking because she is dead right; if I did choose to live or transition to a woman, I would definitely not use the name Sarah. It’s not because I dislike Sarah (it’s me now so that would be appalling), it’s something deeper. But to explain why I need to go back in time a bit.

Pictured – go back in time literally as opposed to indulging in some glorious 1940’s fashions.

Confession time; I hate my name in real life. I don’t tell people that, but it’s a naff name, very popular in the 70’s and there’s a funny/not funny story about it. My name is Ian. I was going to be a Scott or a Nicola depending on the sex (I like Nicola but more on that later) but as well as being born with a messed up set of sexual characteristics I also had one of those bloody awful births you hear about. Back then (and yeah, I do feel ancient describing this) if your mother had problems during child birth rather than going for a C section early they let the baby fight in the birth canal and then yank them out with effectively a pair of metal clamps. I had that ‘fun’ experience and they were pretty sure I was brain damaged by the experience.

On top of being told their child was potentially inter-sexed my parents were warned that I would more than likely have severe learning difficulties; basically my head was squeezed almost to a point during the pulling process.

So out when Scott (and obviously Nicola) and in came a three letter name I could possibly spell. Plus no middle name as it would confuse my low IQ’d mind. The irony is delicious; my IQ measured 176 when tested at the age of nine so either the brain rewired or there’s a lot of give in that chunk of cauliflower when you’re young and full of stem cells.

Anyway, the point is I don’t like the name I was given. I miss not having a middle-name although the ‘parents gave me a name I could probably spell’ is always an amusing pub tale (if I ignore the horrified looks people with empathy give me when I give that story)’.

Pictured – I literally can’t think of a three letter name for a woman. Answers on a postcard….

When I started dressing names weren’t on the agenda; I dressed from a very young age for the effect and feeling it gave me, which is another of those interesting things that point to this compulsion being more than just a sexual fetish, as I was dressing from the age of six only and didn’t get any sexual feelings until twelve or so.

After the confused period when I was deciding whether or not I was a crossdresser or not I started to call myself a woman’s name while dressing. And that name was a derivation of my male name – I went for Diane, partly because my own name was in there and partly because I had a huge thing for the fashions of the late Princess Diana.

Pictured – my 1980’s Diana style dress gets a lot of use for some reason.

I’ll come back to that in a bit as it’s a very important point; the use of feminised version (to a point) of my own name really says something to me about the mindset.

After Diane I played with the name ‘Julie’ for a bit. I’ve always thought of Julie as a particularly feminine name and I was going for as femm as I could. I switched to Debbie for a bit (my Flickr account which has been going for a long time is actually Debbie Lewis-Smith (no idea why I went for double-barrelled other than it sounded posh). Eventually I switched to Sarah, only about four or so years ago.

I’ve blogged about it before but the main reasons for Sarah were a: my first proper girlfriend, when I was around 11 years old, was called Sarah and b: it’s an old name, which ties in nicely with the whole retro feel I have been trying to adopt for a while.

Pictured – yes, this picture has nothing to do with the blog but I like it. Awfully cold though, but I guess that’s the point of wearing nothing but fragments of black lace.

So that’s the history. And now to answer, or at least try, the question from my dear friend.

*If* I chose to go full time, or to be more, well, serious about adopting a female role I absolutely wouldn’t use the name Sarah. And the reason is quite simple; Sarah has been a transition name. What I mean by that is that Sarah has too much baggage for me; I experimented with a lot of looks, some frankly erotic/sexual stuff as well, and Sarah feels like a bridge between the drab me and the feminine me. If I chose to go down the route of discarding the drab me, and believe me I’ve thought about it a lot lately, I would want a clean break and a clean start; no history, no baggage, nothing.

The concept of a name is hugely important. You get given one when you don’t have a choice, and most people are fine with going with that, but for us people who actively don’t like either the person we are or the body state we were dealt, the name is an anchor to a state we don’t like. As I said, I hate my name for a number of reasons; so much I’ve adopted a nickname and only really answer to that at work and home.

Your name is you and the ability to choose it is a massive thing that the majority of people don’t get a chance to do. It’s a chance for a rewrite, a clean slate.

Pictured – Sarah. Or Julia. Or maybe another name.

I see a lot of social network accounts for t-girls, crossdressers and transitionners, where the name they have chosen is a feminisation of their actual name. For some people that’s a big thing; subtly changing their name means that they still can feel themselves, even though the name is the feminine version (Pauline, Stephanie, Joanne etc). That never worked for me because I needed a distinction between her and him; even Diane was too close. See, for me when I started this interesting pink road, the female part of me was a cry for help, a statement of rebellion. I needed her to be almost equal and opposite to him. At the start and for a long time her was a pretence, a mask, something distant from him.

And this brings me to the other question/statement that inspired this blog. In the last four years or so the third person has almost completely disappeared. I now describe my ups and downs, my experiences, as me rather than her or him. And this leads me on to a massive revelation.

He no longer exists.

Pictured – even topless I can’t really see him any more…..

I know, dramatic statement, but it’s the truth. The person who started writing this blog, primarily as a way to express things deep inside I’d never seen, has crumbled slowly away. Maybe it’s the tinkering with the hormones, maybe it was realisation during Covid that all the things that ‘he’ thought were important weren’t. Either way the person who writes these blogs is a very different person to the one that started writing them four or so years ago.

And hence the change of tone. I’m a hybrid now; day to day, during work, I’m kinda the same old person but I’m not. When I accidentally/intentionally came out to my transitioned friend/colleague at work a while back she said a couple of things that struck me heavily. She said there was ‘something’ about me, the way I talked, the body language, that wasn’t male any more, and that it had changed subtly but noticeably over the last year.

When I work from home and I’m on video conferences my legs are always crossed, feminine style, under the desk. I like the way it feels and the way it makes me feel. It feels natural.

The reason I no longer refer to Sarah as ‘her’ when I write these blogs is I’ve past the point of balance; I’m more Sarah under the covers now than I am him. And what’s even more shocking and worrying is that it isn’t shocking or worrying at all. It just feels normal.

Pictured – well ‘normal’ has a lot of latitude nowadays.

So, long story short; if (or when) I choose to jump, to put away his clothes and get mine out on a day to day basis, I won’t be ‘Sarah’. I’ll be something new, something clean, a fresh blackboard with pink trim ready to be written on. Sarah has as much, if not more, baggage than he did, and that baggage was like scar tissue; the learning process, the acceptance, the changes. I’ve done things with Sarah that the new me is a little ashamed of, the fetish outfits, the blatant self-hate. One of the lovely things about me right now is I’m, at least internally, at peace for the first time pretty much ever.

Yes, it could be the effect of smearing Estrogen gel on my upper leg every night (along with taking two high strength isoflavin tablets). But I like to think it’s saying a fond goodbye to ‘Ian’, who, as Caitlyn Jenner said in the documentary I watched (and yes, I don’t have a huge amount of time for her in terms of her politics but that documentary was stunning) ‘did his job well under pressure that was almost unbearable’. He suffered, he tried, he erred, but he got me here.

Anyway, way too deep for a Sunday night (plus three beers down). But I hope that answer why Sarah may not be around for a long time, and why I now talk about me and him instead of me and her.

Stay beautiful and be honest with yourself. In the long term it makes sense.

Pictured – and *that* is for another blog dear readers…..

8 thoughts on “[Philosophy] What’s in a Name? Everything….

  1. I completely hear you!

    The only difference I have from your story on names (apart from the origins of the one I was given) is that I rather like the idea of not having a name that I have chosen (she says, using a name she has totally chosen).

    But, apart from that, I really enjoyed reading your thoughts on this and found much that resonated with me. Not that this is required to recognise good writing and a treatise on identity via names. Thank you, honestly, fo writing this post.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I was a forceps birth, my chest is a bit convex as a result I believe and IQ not as high as yours, but who’s counting :-).

    My name is a feminisation of my name. I’ve used it for a long time, but really only by me. I’ve started adding sissy to it so people don’t think I’m actually a woman and that is an interesting topic.

    Lots of three letter female names: Eve, Joy, Sue, Fay, Liz, Kaz, although some of those are just abbreviations.

    Great blog post and lovely pictures. Thanks!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I really enjoy your insightful blog posts Sarah. πŸ™‚
    What’s in a name eh? Almost everything really. They all come with connotations and expectations. We are as a group kind of lucky in that we kinda get to choose a name which (we hope!) reflects us more accurately than any of the ones foisted upon us by our parents. It may take us a while to settle on one but I think that’s part of us discovering who we are. I still use my ‘old’ femme name more as a pseudonym now than anything else. Including on this account. πŸ™‚ XXX
    I really am so sorry to hear about the events surrounding your birth and naming sweetie. And I can understand why you don’t want to be associated with ‘his’ name anymore. For your answer on a postcard, I can only think of Ida. Still three letters and complete in itself.
    I think we all have baggage too. And again I think that’s part of us working out who we are – warts and all. But I do like the idea of you becoming more at one with your femininity Sarah. πŸ™‚ I think that if it is a route to personal happiness and contentment then it’s all good. I hope that one day I will be able to join you there.
    Stay safe and stay well my dearest friend. 😘

    Fi-Fi (Rochelle)

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Hi I’ve read your blog for a fair while, following you on insta & FL. Love how you write. I too was pulled out with the tongs, have questionable genitalia etc, didn’t pop out right I have Spina Bifida and hydrocephalus. As for names; both I use are stereotypically Irish Catholic. My female name came at University in the late 90’s and Erin has stuck ever since apart from a brief period as Aisling (Irish for dream or vision) inspired by the Shane MacGowen song, I love the name but living over here in the UK no one can spell it!

    Liked by 1 person

  5. “…that it had changed subtly but noticeably over the last year.”

    The process of change and perhaps a merging: that there’s no him or her, just you. FWIW, I think not having those barriers is a good thing. That you can – and have, reading what you’ve put – accept those aspects of who you are as a person.

    PS: great post, BTW

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Very well expressed. The nuances of “a rose by any other name”…. and the freedom of that! And the challenge of that.
    Quite enjoyed the read…
    Just found you and am fantastically enamored!
    Cant wait to read more!
    Thanks for being that bright light I endlessly adore!!!

    Charlotte Violet Maise

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.